Trump’s Fate Belongs in the Hands of 12 Ordinary Citizens


This article, penned by Jesse Wegman on August 27, 2023, for The New York Times, delves into the significance of the jury system in the American democratic process, drawing parallels between the classic film “12 Angry Men” and the recent legal challenges faced by former President Donald Trump. The film, which revolves around the deliberations of a jury in a murder case, underscores the vital role that juries play in upholding the principles of democracy. The article emphasizes the impartiality of the jury system, where ordinary citizens are summoned to determine the guilt or innocence of an individual, irrespective of their personal biases.

Wegman reflects on the recent events where Donald Trump was charged in Fulton County, Georgia, for his alleged involvement in racketeering related to overturning the state’s 2020 presidential vote. While impeachment efforts against Trump were thwarted by partisan politics in the Senate, and the 14th Amendment’s disqualification clause, which could potentially bar Trump from holding public office, remains a contentious issue, the author posits that a criminal jury might be the most democratic solution to ascertain Trump’s accountability for the events of January 6.

The article underscores the sanctity of the jury system, where jurors, despite their familiarity with high-profile defendants like Trump, are bound by the law and procedural rules to ensure a fair trial. Constitutional scholar Akhil Reed Amar is quoted emphasizing the importance of juries as a means of political participation and self-governance. The Founding Fathers of America, recognizing the significance of juries, enshrined the right to a jury trial in the Constitution.

In conclusion, while juries are not infallible, they offer a more objective avenue for justice than partisan politics. Entrusting the fate of individuals, even someone as polarizing as Trump, to a jury embodies the essence of a society governed by the rule of law, where facts and legal principles take precedence over biases.

Wegman, Jesse. “Trump’s Fate Belongs in the Hands of 12 Ordinary Citizens.” The New York Times, 27 Aug. 2023.

Summary provided by ChatGPT


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.